Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need to order in advance?

Yes. We often sell out at our NYC location, so it's best to place orders ahead for pickup. For orders that require delivery or shipping, allow 2-4 days; we will do our best to make your requested delivery date. 

Where do you deliver?   

We deliver all of our products throughout Westchester County and NYC. 

We ship nationwide with Goldbely.
In order to assure quality and freshness we only ship tins, tubes and cakes.

We specialize in special events and corporate orders. We will deliver to New Jersey and Long Island for large orders. Please contact us at with your inquiries.

Are there any shops where I can purchase Baked in Color cookies?

Baked in Color has a kiosk location at TurnstyleNYC, 58th street and Broadway, the underground market at Columbus Circle. Our hours of operation are: Monday - Friday, 12:30 - 7:00. Saturdays 12:00-5:00. We often sell out of our cookies, so place orders ahead for pick up.  

Where do you ship? 

We ship nationwide with Goldbelly.

In order to assure quality and freshness we only ship tins, tubes and cakes.

Cookies are shipped the same day they are baked to ensure peak freshness. We ship Monday-Wednesday for Tuesday-Friday delivery. Order ahead and we will do our best to deliver cookies on your requested date.   

How many Baked in Color cookies should I order? 

We recommend 2 classics, 4-5 minis, or 8-12 bite size cookies per person. 

Do Baked in Color cookies contain nuts? 

With the exception of our Reese’s brownie cookie squares, our treats are nut-free. All ingredients and materials used are nut-free, but we bake in a facility where nut ingredients are used. 

What is the shelf life for Baked in Color products? 

Our cookies are best eaten within two days of delivery. Our products can be frozen for up to three months. 

How should I store my Baked in Color treats?

We recommend storing your cookies in sealed plastic or air tight jars to maintain freshness. Cookies can be frozen for up to 3 months. To freeze, place cookies in a freezer bag. Thaw cookies for one hour before serving. Add ice cream to frozen cookies for delicious and colorful ice cream sandwiches.

What is the nutritional information for Baked in Color cookies? 

Contact us for nutritional information at 

Can I customize my order? 

Yes. You can specify the size and colors of the cookies you’d like. We can also customize packaging for special events. We specialize in personal and corporate gifting and catering. Contact us at with your inquiries.

Do you cater events, personal and corporate?  

Yes.  We specialize in personal and corporate gifting and catering.  We can match the colors of your event, your company logo or stick with our best selling rainbow treats. We can provide treats for the event or favors to go. Contact us at with your inquiries.

Will you include a gift message with my order? 

Yes. We will include a personalized gift message with your order.

Can you write on the cookie cakes? 

No, we customize our cookies with color. We can deliver a personalized gift message with your order. 

Have additional questions? 

Simply fill out the form here, and a member of our team will get back to you shortly.